Top 10 Ways to Eat Cookie Butter

Sweet Delicious Ways to Eat Cookie Butter

cookie butter 1

I had heard of the elusive Cookie Butter but have always avoided it. My reason was I LOVE Cookies and I LOVE Butter. What would happen if they both came together. Well with all the talk and  proclamations of love for Cookie Butter, I caved. Yesterday, I walked into Trader Joes and walked out with 4 jars. That may seem like a lot but let me tell you it is not enough. Now I was not selfish and 2 of the jars were promptly mailed to Rachelle (who doesn’t have a Trader Joes near her.). I then couldn’t wait to return home and slowly peeled off the cover to the creamy variety and revealed the decadence known as Cookie Butter. 

Since we were in the car my husband,daughter and I used our fingers (Hey, don’t judge!) and quickly decided we had been missing out. My husband asked why I had never told him about this stuff before. My daughter just asked for the jar!

As we drove along we then decided to try the Crunchy. It was just as yummy and I had to fight my husband off before he finished the jar. As we drove along he asked me how are you supposed to eat it. I told him with a spoon! I got “The Look”. So when I came home I decided to come up with a list of 10 ways to eat Cookie Butter.


I am going to insert my disclaimer here: I am not responsible for any addiction you may develop, any pounds gained, any digits lost in a fight over the jar, any crumbs in the bed or car, and any other incidents that may result from your consumption of Cookie Butter. 

Top 10 Ways to Eat Cookie Butter

  1. Replace your peanut butter with Cookie Butter on a PB&J.
  2. Frost brownies with it.
  3. Use it as the filling between layers of cake. (or as frosting)
  4. Use it in place of syrup on pancakes or waffles.
  5. Dip graham crackers or animal crackers into it.
  6. Heat it up and drizzle over French Vanilla Ice cream (Who am I kidding any kind of ice cream will do)
  7. Serve it with Apple Slices
  8. Dress up Toast or Bagel for a sweet treat.
  9. Heat it and serve it fondue style.
  10. MY Favorite — USE A SPOON!!


Don’t worry if you do not live near a Trader Joes’ you can enjoy some of this delicious goodness anywhere Amazon ships.

Follow this link to order——–>> Cookie Butter

Do you have an attachment to Trader Joes’ Cookie Butter?

Share your ideas for enjoying or trying to quit below in the comments section.


without text

Apple Pie Recipe

Apple Pie Recipe using cookie butter . This is a fun and quick recipe to make apple pie. It is one you will not forget. I happen to love cookie butter.

cookie butter shake 3

Cookie Butter Apple Pie Shake

Cookie Butter Marshmallow Popcorn

Cookie Butter Marshmallow Popcorn

Variety Pack – Trader Joe’s: 1) Speculoos Smooth Cookie Butter; 2) Speculoos Crunchy Cookie Butter; 3) Speculoos Cookie & Cocoa Swirl (Total 3 Jars)

Biscoff Cookie Butter Spread

PB Crave Peanut Butter

Trader Joes Cookie Butter Sandwich Cookies

Trader Joe’s Speculoos Cookies

3 ingredient cookie

Easy Cool Whip Cookie Recipe

Kids will love this Low Calorie Funfetti Cookies Recipe

Kids will also love this Low Calorie Funfetti Cookies Recipe

Weight Watchers Mixed Berry Cobbler Cake Recipe

Artale Biscuit Maker Cheese Dessert Sticks Spritz Cookie Press with Disks and Icing Tips, Dessert Decorator Cookie Maker Gun Kit Set

Clear Cookie Press Gun Kit with 16 Discs and 6 Icing Tips

Sunbeam FPSBFCM40 Fortune Cookie Maker

Wilton 2304-1050 101-Piece Cookie Cutter Set

Do you love to cook using your Instant Pot Pressure Cooker XL and Crockpot? Do you want to discover new recipes or maybe share yours? We'd love to chat with you. Join our Pressure Cooker XL and Crockpot Recipes Facebook Group community!


Cook, Baker, Phototaker, Fitness Mover and Shaker, Cupcake Tester, Deal Maker, Adventurous Undertaker, Do Good "Deeder", Teacher, Mom, Wife, Patriot for Life & Giver of Good Advice - RealAdviceGal

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

Leave a Reply: